For most orders under 100 pieces, DTF wins on cost and turnaround. Screen printing pulls ahead only once you're past roughly 150 pieces in one or two colors, where its per-piece price drops below what DTF can match. Below that line, DTF is usually cheaper, faster to turn around, and handles full-color art that screen printing can't touch without adding a screen per color.
That's the short version. Here's the actual math behind it, pulled straight from real per-piece pricing, not a rule of thumb.
DTF Pricing by Quantity and Size
DTF (direct-to-film) is priced per piece, per print location, based on print size and order quantity. Transfer material cost is built into these rates, there's no separate materials line.
| Quantity | Small (up to 4"x4") | Standard (up to 10"x10") | Large (up to 12"x16") |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24-47 | $4.00 | $6.50 | $9.00 |
| 48-71 | $3.25 | $5.25 | $7.50 |
| 72-99 | $2.75 | $4.50 | $6.25 |
| 100+ | $2.25 | $3.75 | $5.25 |
Minimum order is 24 pieces. A $40 setup fee applies per design, waived on reorders of the same design.
Screen Printing Pricing by Quantity and Colors
We don't run screen printing in-house, so these are typical market rates rather than a Loyal Brand quote, useful for comparison, not a price we'll invoice you at. Screen printing is priced per color: every additional color means another screen, so cost scales with color count in a way DTF doesn't.
| Quantity | 1 Color | 2 Colors | 3 Colors | 4 Colors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12-23 | $6.50 | $7.75 | $9.00 | $10.25 |
| 24-71 | $4.15 | $5.15 | $6.15 | $7.15 |
| 72-144 | $2.45 | $3.45 | $4.45 | $5.45 |
| 145-299 | $1.75 | $2.35 | $2.95 | $3.55 |
| 300-499 | $1.55 | $1.80 | $2.05 | $2.30 |
Typical market setup runs $20-$35 per screen, per color, on top of the per-piece rate. Dark garments usually carry a $0.50-$0.80 per-print premium for the extra ink layer needed to block the fabric color. Full color or photo-realistic art isn't practical on a screen press at all, past 4-6 colors the setup cost and registration difficulty make it a bad fit, that's DTF or DTG territory.
What the Numbers Actually Say
Line up the closest brackets and the pattern is clear. At 72-99 pieces, DTF standard-size runs $4.50 a piece. Screen printing's 72-144 bracket for a single color is $2.45, less than half. That gap is real: if you're printing one color at real bulk, screen printing is cheaper, full stop.
But most logos aren't one flat color. Match DTF's standard rate against screen printing's 4-color rate in the same 72-144 range and screen printing runs $5.45, DTF is the cheaper option at $4.50. The crossover point depends entirely on how many colors are in the design, not just quantity.
Small prints under 4x4 inches favor DTF even harder at low-to-mid volume: $2.75 a piece at 72-99 units, a price screen printing doesn't approach until deep into the 145+ bracket even at one color.
Durability
DTF prints hold up to 50-100 washes in standard use, and stayed in top condition through a 50-wash cold-wash, air-dry test cited by DTF supplier DTFHub. That same source describes well-cured screen prints as lasting a comparable 50 to 100 wash cycles. Neither method has a clear durability edge over the other when applied correctly, the failure modes differ more than the lifespan does: screen prints are more prone to cracking if under-cured, DTF prints are more prone to slight fading at the high end of that range while staying flexible. We've found the same holds true in our own DTF work, prints that resist fading and cracking through repeated washes when the transfer is pressed correctly.
When to Use Each
| Situation | Better Fit |
|---|---|
| Under 100 pieces, any color count | DTF |
| Full-color, gradient, or photo-realistic art | DTF |
| 150+ pieces, 1-2 flat colors | Screen printing |
| Need it fast, no time for screen setup | DTF |
| Simple logo, very large bulk run (300+) | Screen printing |
FAQ
Is DTF better than screen printing?
Neither wins outright, it depends on quantity and color count. DTF is cheaper and faster below roughly 100-150 pieces and handles full-color art screen printing can't. Screen printing gets cheaper than DTF once you're past that volume in one or two colors, since its per-piece cost keeps dropping at scale in a way DTF's doesn't.
What's the difference between screen print transfers and DTF?
A screen print transfer is still screen printing, ink pushed through a mesh screen onto transfer paper first, then heat-applied, so it inherits screen printing's per-color setup cost. DTF prints the full-color design onto film with a printer, then powders and heat-presses it, no screens, no per-color setup, and no practical color limit.
Ordering shirts for a team, school, or event?
Skip the sizing guesswork. Send us your group and we'll spec the right blanks and sizes, then quote it. 4.9 stars across 340+ reviews.
Get a Free QuoteDTF vs screen printing durability, which lasts longer?
Both hold up to roughly 50-100 washes when done correctly, per DTFHub's own wash testing. There's no clear winner on raw lifespan. Screen prints are more likely to crack if under-cured; DTF prints are more likely to show slight fading at the far end of that wash range.
Silk screen vs DTF, what should I pick for a small order?
DTF, in almost every case. Silk screen (screen printing) carries a per-screen setup cost that doesn't make sense below roughly 100-150 pieces, and it can't do full color without stacking multiple screens. DTF has no per-color penalty and a lower minimum (24 pieces) built for smaller runs.
Can screen printing do full color designs?
Technically yes, but it stops making practical sense past about 4-6 colors. Each color needs its own screen and its own setup charge, and lining up more than a handful of screens gets expensive and harder to register accurately. Full color, gradients, and photo-realistic art are DTF's actual strength.
Not sure which method fits your order? See how DTF compares to embroidery for polo decoration, or read the case for DTF over DTG printing. If fabric choice is still an open question, start with how to choose the right material for custom t-shirts. For file prep basics before either method, see RGB vs CMYK for print design.
Send us your quantity, colors, and design, we'll tell you straight which method fits. Reach out at john@theloyalbrand.com or call 410-861-0633.
